What were hindumuslim relations in india before the. Sardar patel and indian muslims an analysis of his. Indias partition and the conflict over kashmir, a muslimmajority princely state ruled by a hindu dynasty, were driven by local interests and philosophy, including the twonation theory, which held that the muslims of british india should be granted their own country, pakistan. As evidence, the league pointed to hindumuslim riots in the. In a way it is also a lament for loss and continued diminishing of the composite culture. Jizya tax clearly did more harm than good to muslim hindu relations and a prudent ruler would have avoided using it.
In the first half of the twentieth century, they were. The study of human behaviour and social t ensions in india. In the british province of bengal before it was first divided in 1905, muslims were a small majority. Materialized, externalized and archived, living memory is not valued as an art to a civilized existence. India and pakistan are countries that were born through violence. Oct 11, 2018 even after more than 1,000 years, recent trends indicate further radicalization and isolation of indias muslims.
Aug 10, 2017 how the partition of india happened and why its effects are still felt today. Zakaria explains, patel was, in fact one of the first lieutenants of gandhiji to propagate and carry forward the mission of hindumuslim unity. But by the early nineteenforties their relationship had grown so. That, in fact, was the root of the hindumuslim divide but in utter disregard for the truth, indian historians and politicians together with the british historians to hide their role in dividing india, blamed the muslims, the muslim league and pakistans creator mohammad ali jinnah for the hindumuslim conflict through the twonation theory. A stunning first novel, set during the violent 1947 partition of india, about uprooted children and their journeys to safety as india is rent into two nations. It was the british who divided india, the muslims just. Mar 16, 2019 thus, hindu muslim conflict in south asia derives from no one particular factor, but is a function of the friction between different communities with different modernizing visions. The partition of india and pakistan one year before partition255 million hindus. The overwhelming, but predominantly hindu, protest against the partition of bengal and the fear of reforms favouring the hindu majority, now led the muslim elite in india to meet with the new viceroy lord minto in 1906 and ask for separate electorates for muslims. Understanding the muslim mind examines the lives of eight. Iqbals hindu relations this above all khushwant singh unity in diversity i am beholden to p. His trusted friend and advisor abul fazl wrote a book. I learned a lot, but cant say that i am wholly satisfied with the book. In 1947, before partition, muslims represented one fourth of the total indian population 94.
Muslim hindu religious interactions in the mughal empire. Hindus live with a legacy of domination by muslim and christian rulers that stretches back many centuriesin northern india, to the delhi sultanate established at the beginning of the th century. Understanding the indian muslim frontline the hindu. Hindumuslim relations in india questia online library. Most muslims lived in the eastern districts of bengal where they were more than threequarters of the population. Hindumuslim communal riots in india i 19471986 sciences. Immediately, there began one of the greatest migrations in human history. Hindumuslim relations in prepartition lahore india of the past.
Why is there so much hate between hindus and muslims in. Nov 26, 2016 in the case of the essentially hostile nature of indopak relations, however, i could decide almost as soon as i started to write the book, that its modern phase began shortly after the partition. Home browse religion asian religions hindumuslim relations in india hindumuslim relations in india the relationship between hindus and muslims is stereotypically characterized by conflict, rooted in the deep and flawed division of the former british colony of india into separate hindu and muslim states. Aug 17, 2017 indias muslims and the price of partition. The northern, predominantly muslim sections of india became the nation of pakistan, while the southern and majority hindu section became the republic of india. In august, 1947, when, after three hundred years in india, the british finally left, the subcontinent was partitioned into two independent nation states. It was the muslim leagues threats in 1946 that if denied pakistan the muslims would turn hindustan into a kabristan graveyard. Similarly, hindu muslim riots in india date back to hundreds of years before any british official set foot on the subcontinent. There have been periodic instances of violence against muslims in india from before its partition from pakistan in 1947, frequently in the form of mob attacks on muslims by hindus that form a pattern of sporadic sectarian violence between the hindu and muslim communities.
Hindumuslim relations in india hindumuslim relations in india the relationship between hindus and muslims is stereotypically characterized by conflict, rooted in the deep and flawed division of the former british colony of india into separate hindu and muslim states. Indias muslims didnt feel secure and werent flourishing before the b. Relations between sikhs and muslims are good infact much better than hindumuslim relation. And at the time of partition they had a choicethey could go to pakistanbut they didnt go. Illegitimate son not entitle for partition and share but for maintenance only. Hindu relations with islam and christianity are in some ways quite different from the ties and tensions that bind together religions of indian origin. Hindus and muslims lived amicably in undivided india until britain colonised the country, promoted conflict between the two communities, pursued a policy of divide and rule and eventually presided. Hindus and muslims cooperated in this endeavor, though the later partition into separate hindu and muslim polities plus the precursor tension to it would predicate future conflict. The bloody legacy of indian partition the new yorker. Indias partition and the conflict over kashmir, a muslimmajority. Rafiq zakaria, one of indias leading intellectuals, with considerable experience of politics at the highest level, deals in this publication with the charge against sardar patel of being antimuslim. Muslim rulers from the north ruled india for close to a thousand years.
Dont forget there are 180 million muslims in this country. Opinion indias muslims and the price of partition the new york. Quotation from the title page of thoughts on pakistan, 1st ed. The price of partition recollection and reflections. Secondly, the postcolonial literature concerning eurocentrism and orientalism confirmed in the western book.
The making of india and pakistan, written by a professor at oxford. Hindumuslim differences by timur kuran and anantdeep singh december 2010 abstract. Knowing that the muslim population in punjab is just 1% i was expecting there will be less influence of islamic culture in pu. In the case of the essentially hostile nature of indopak relations, however, i could decide almost as soon as i started to write the book, that its modern phase began shortly after the partition. Relations between the hindus and the muslims in the. What were hindumuslim relations in india before the british. Sep 11, 2009 this had disastrous consequences on hindu muslim relations later. Rawal of jammu for sending me a photograph of allama iqbals kashmiri brahmin family taken in sialkot in 1931. The muslims and sikhs enjoyed harmonious relationship throughout the rural punjab but the midtwentieth century proved havoc to this peacetime. Various dynasties, the delhi dynasty to the mughals, in succession, ruled india till the british stamped their ascendancy with the final fall the battle of independence in 1. Zakaria explains, patel was, in fact one of the first lieutenants of gandhiji to propagate and. How the partition of india happened and why its effects are still felt today. In 1857, the first freedom struggle, english rulers observed great hindumuslim unity and shocked to see the brotherhood, they planned divide and rule policy to rule easily.
Before i introduce shabana azmi, let me just turn to bill ferguson who is the group. The partition of india was the process of dividing the subcontinent along sectarian lines, which took place in 1947 as india gained its independence from the british raj. The creation and perpetuation of hindumuslim antagonism was the most significant accomplishment of british. Thus, hindumuslim conflict in south asia derives from no one particular factor, but is a function of the friction between different communities with different modernizing visions. Muslimsikh relations in the british punjab, 194047. Mobilizing hindu sensibilities about the sacredness of the land as a whole. Opinion indias muslims and the price of partition the. In this lesson, we will learn about religious tensions in india and the partition of india and pakistan following british rule. Stanford religious historian audrey truschke uncovers a surprising cultural alliance between muslim and hindu elites in early sanskrit. The schizophrenic record of human rights under muslim rule although arbitrary it is practical to analyze muslim rule in two sections as before the mughal period and the mughal period itself. Noakhali pogrom by muslims just before partition should find mention here. A week ago, one morning, around 8 am, i got a call from an unknown number. Oct 06, 2008 to address my ignorance, i turned to this book, the great partition.
This stratification is from the book of the prophet the hadith. Ajaz ashraf, the author of the novel the hour before dawn, is a journalist based in new delhi. It was the british who divided india, the muslims just played. Namaste bhaiya, main kaleem bol raha hun, aap kaise ho greetings sir, i am kalim speaking, how are you. Stroessinger suggest that partition and the indopakistan wars were due to religious ideology, but.
Sep 09, 2015 stanford scholar casts new light on hindu muslim relations. In prepartition india, mahatma gandhi described the social tension between. It is possible that after the khilafat movement the muslims began. List of books and articles about hindumuslim relations in. There has also been a widespread attempt to record oral memories of partition before the. The indian muslim league feared that a hindu dominated state would not be able to appropriately tend to the muslim population. Three perspectives on partition radboud universiteit. Perspective on hindumuslim relations in india researchgate. Abductions and hindumuslim relations in modern bengali novels memory and histmy have a long but ambiguous relationship. Drawing from the indian context, the author explores options for western europe a region grappling with the refugee. How the partition of india happened and why its effects are.
In late 1948, he joined the punjab government as a public relations officer. In 1947, before partition, muslims represented one fourth of the total indian population. Being the other is interesting and insightful book. In conjunction, they demanded proportional legislative representation reflecting. Dec 20, 2019 focus on religious conflict has unfortunately blurred the efforts on resolution of the conflict and the modern day writings look at the hindu muslim issues entirely from a religious point of view. Various dynasties, the delhi dynasty to the mughals, in succession, ruled india till the british stamped their ascendancy with the final fall the battle of independence in 1857, known to the british as the indian mutiny. The bloody partition of the south asian subcontinent into india and pakistan in 1947 added a new dimension. This book reconstructs hindumuslim relations from a european standpoint. Pran seth started his career as a lecturer in political science in a punjab college in lahore in 1946. Sense and sensibility in south asia the news international. Meenakshi jains book explains the leitmotif for hindumuslim relations for over a millennium and demolishes the harmony theory, writes a surya prakash parallel pathways.
The hindumuslim divide was fostered by the british to maintain the raj. William dalrymple on the mutual genocide of hindus, muslims and sikhs in the creation of pakistan and india, and nisid hajaris book, midnights. Adopted son he has right if partition take place after adoption, but if partition take place before adoption he has no right. Sardar patel and indian muslims an analysis of his relations. Essays on hindumuslim relations 17071857 explains the leitmotif for hindumuslim relations for over a millennium and demolishes the harmony theory. The safety valve is that we still have a multicultural mosaic in west bengal, tamil nadu.
Similarly, hindumuslim riots in india date back to hundreds of years before any british official set foot on the subcontinent. This had disastrous consequences on hindu muslim relations later. This conflict between islam and the indian civilisation has been recorded by many. This conflict between islam and the indian civilisation has been recorded by many travellers, court historians, writers and poets, and. Both nehru and jinnah used communal tensions as a why to gain political power. The struggle for political power between the hindumuslim elites happened after the british parliament. Aug 14, 2019 the partition of india was the process of dividing the subcontinent along sectarian lines, which took place in 1947 as india gained its independence from the british raj. They tried to create a harmonious religiously pluralistic society under muslim hegemony, something that had never before been seen in.
Hindumuslim communal riots in india i 19471986 sciences po. Certain muslim rulers broke hindu temples and destroyed the idols of god. The muslims of south asia made the transition to modern economic life more slowly than the regions hindus. Doc hindu muslim relations before partition in india. Foreword price of partition is not only an authentic presentation of the chronology of events and circumstances leading to the partition of india but the sigh of anguish of a patriot who swore by the unity and integrity of india, and harmony between the hindu and muslim brethren of our sacred land. The work of scholars of indian religions like david lorenzen and andrew nicholson shows that there was a clear sense of difference between hindu and muslim communities long before british rule. About the book from the early twenties to the late forties, india was caught in the vortex of conflicting political moves which continued to disturb hindumuslim relations. For the ink was not yet dry on the 1947 charter of sovereignty before what had been one great single nation under british rule became split into two sullenly hostile. How the partition of india happened and why its effects.
So when you have political groups that are dictating which books can and cannot be. Focus on religious conflict has unfortunately blurred the efforts on resolution of the conflict and the modern day writings look at the hindumuslim issues. The contacts between the hindus and the muslims are as old as. Gandhis tenacious quest for hindumuslim unity part iv the riottorn history of hindumuslim relations, 19201940 part v such barbaric mutual violence shows an utter lack of unity chapter viii muslim alternative to pakistan. The most dramatic series of events during the period from 1937 to 1947, which witnessed several crucial developments, is a sharp oscillation in hindu muslim relations. Hinduism is a way of life of the hindu people of india, their diaspora, and some other regions. Jul 15, 20 after these initial events in 1978, hyderabad was to experience communal riots almost on a yearly basis, particularly during the ganesh festival, the public celebration of which was encouraged by the then chief minister chenna reddy in order to serve his own political ends see chapter 4 in hindumuslim communal riots in india ii 1986. Stanford religious historian audrey truschke uncovers a surprising cultural alliance between muslim and hindu elites in. Additionally, the growth of the indian economy has contributed incentives to both communities to quell rumors and prejudice as they may spread and provoke rounds of violence. Hindu extremists demolish babri mosque in ayodhya, triggering widespread hindumuslim violence in 1992 afp his work, instead, focuses largely on middleclass, urban, north indian muslims as he argues that there has been an awakening among indias muslims which is driving them away from their supposed historical insularity and conservatism. He chooses an unusual approach to explore the psyche of the south asian muslim and the larger question of hindumuslim relations.
The hindumuslim divide in india remains a potential source of communal violence or even a civil war. It is possible that after the khilafat movement the muslims began to view themselves, not as a community but as a nation. The roots of violence against muslims lie in indias history, stemming from lingering resentment toward the islamic domination of india during the middle ages, policies established by the countrys british colonizers, the violent partition of india into a muslim pakistan, and a hindu majority, but secular india with a large but minority muslim population. What began with a squabble about the division of assets after partition, and went on to bitter conflict over the future of disputed princely states such. If not anything else it shows the sheer complexity of the situation of hindumuslim relations in pre and post partition india. Fifthly it led to a series of hindu muslim riots between 1920 and 1939 details of which are given in dr ambedkars book. In her book india before europe, she writes, although the religious.
Kiran doshi on his new novel and how it came to be the hindu. Buy hindumuslim relations in india book online at low. Stanford scholar casts new light on hindumuslim relations. The origins of hindumuslim conflict in south asia the diplomat. This book makes a critical appraisal of hindu muslim relations in india, in the wake of political developments in uttar pradesh during the period from 1937 to 1947. Opinion was divided on all sides whether a strong central government or a loose confederation of hindu and muslim states was the goal. Son void marriage and annulled marriagenot entitle. I was peacefully walking in garden and was surprised by the call. This single paragraph in jains book explains the leitmotif for hindumuslim relations for over a millennium and effectively demolishes the harmony theory. History of hindumuslim relations is marred by bitter communal riots before and after indias independence. The boundaries between islam and hinduism remained flexible until british colonial. After indias partition, he helped set up a new hindi daily called amar bharat in delhi. The origins of hindumuslim conflict in south asia the.
The rural punjab, the real punjab far away from the disease of communalism was a centre of merriments, festivals, folklore, sports and cultural gatherings. Given this background, meenakshi jains parallel pathways is a pathbreaking work, seeking to blast the myths visavis hindumuslim relations from 1707 to the great uprising of 1857. As jain points out, a school of historians believes that the revolt of 1857 was the last notable manifestation of hindumuslim unity. Even before the birth of the prophet, there existed settle ments of arab traders on. The hindumuslim divide and the 1947 partition of india. Muslim and hindu conflict in india and the partition of india. Aug 23, 2018 the work of scholars of indian religions like david lorenzen and andrew nicholson shows that there was a clear sense of difference between hindu and muslim communities long before british rule. Islam in india existed in communities along the arab coastal trade routes in bengal, gujarat, and kerala as soon as the religion originated and had gained early acceptance in the arabian peninsula, though the first incursion through sea by the new muslim successor states of the arab world occurred around 636 ce or 643 ad, during the rashidun caliphate, long before any arab army reached the.
561 1178 609 998 215 725 1389 870 365 621 981 304 1045 722 279 179 529 391 555 1149 901 409 727 390 1399 1136 195 595 80 1428 10 130 40 995 842